First Team

   --- Keegan Fees, sr., Gettysburg: The midfielder served as a key link between the Warriors' defense, which produced 11 shutouts, and an offense which averaged four goals per game. He scored one goal and had eight assists.
   --- Brady Griest, sr., Biglerville: A repeat All-Area first-team selection, Griest tied for the team lead with 19 goals and topped the Canners with 15 assists to lead an offense with was shut out in only one game this season.
   --- Scott Hess, soph., South Western: The sophomore became the Mustangs' chief scoring threat throughout the season as he finished with 12 goals and added five assists for a team which reached the YAIAA tournament.
   --- Chris Meyer, sr., South Western: Meyer, a YAIAA Coaches All-Star first-team selection, was a key reason the Mustangs finished with a winning record in YAIAA Division I. He posted 105 saves and produced three shutouts
   --- Fabian Reyes, sr., Biglerville: An All-Area second-team selection last season, Reyes earned the YAIAA Division III coaches' and the All-Area first-team nod after tying for the team lead with 19 goals. He also produced 13 assists.
   --- Tyler Smith, sr., Gettysburg: This repeat first-team choice also earned a spot on the Mid-Penn Colonial Division first team after he posted nine goals and 12 assists from his midfield position for the Warriors.
   --- Jon Tarbox, soph., Gettysburg: A Mid-Penn Colonial second-team selection, Tarbox received his inaugural first-team All-Area nod after ranking second for the Warriors with 12 goals. He also led Gettysburg with 13 assists.
   --- Zach Tarbox, sr., Gettysburg: The repeat All-Area Player of the Year set a Hanover area career scoring record after a 39-goal campaign which led Gettysburg to a 12-0 Mid-Penn Colonial Division record. Tarbox also posted seven assists.
   --- Caleb Wagner, sr., Fairfield: One of the Hanover area's leading distributors of the soccer ball, Wagner led Fairfield's high-octane attack with 16 assists. He also posted eight goals for a team which averaged more than four scores per game.
   --- Dan Warner, jr., Fairfield: The second-leading scorer for the Green Knights with 15 goals, Warner was one of the few Hanover area players who also earned double digits in assists as he dealt 10 helpers during the 2011 season.
   --- Devin Wilt, soph., Fairfield: Earning his second All-Area first-team nod in two years, Wilt was the Hanover area's second-leading goal scorer with 25 goals. Wilt also earned 10 assists, giving him 15 in his first two varsity seasons.

Second Team

   --- Leo Arrequin, jr., Bermudian Springs
   --- Chase Flickinger, fr., Spring Grove
   --- Nathan Long, sr., Biglerville
   --- Luke McFalls, sr., New Oxford
   --- Anders Nordberg, jr., Fairfield
   --- Chris Roberts, sr., Fairfield
   --- Andrew Slater, fr., South Western
   --- Joseph Schmitz, jr., Gettysburg
   --- Brandon Study, sr., Littlestown
   --- Richard Weidner, sr., Biglerville
   --- Harley Weigle, jr., Biglerville